Introduction
New Buffalo, Michigan, a charming lakeside town nestled near the Indiana border, is more than just sun-kissed beaches and breathtaking sunsets over Lake Michigan. While its scenic beauty undoubtedly draws visitors in, a delectable secret lies hidden beneath its relaxed exterior: a thriving and diverse culinary scene waiting to be explored. From casual breakfast nooks to elegant waterfront restaurants, New Buffalo offers a delightful array of dining experiences that cater to every palate and budget. This guide will take you on a culinary journey through New Buffalo, highlighting the best places to savor its unique flavors and create lasting memories. Forget the ordinary; prepare to discover the delicious side of New Buffalo, Michigan.
Morning Delights: Breakfast and Brunch in New Buffalo
Start your day off right with a hearty breakfast or a leisurely brunch at one of New Buffalo’s many inviting eateries. Whether you’re craving fluffy pancakes, savory omelets, or a simple cup of freshly brewed coffee, you’ll find something to satisfy your morning hunger.
The Whistle Stop Cafe
One local favorite is *The Whistle Stop Cafe*. This cozy cafe, with its vintage railway decor, offers a charming and welcoming atmosphere. Their menu boasts classic breakfast staples with a touch of creativity. The “Whistle Stop Special,” a plate piled high with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, golden hash browns, and a homemade biscuit, is a perennial favorite. They also offer a selection of delicious pancakes, waffles, and omelets, all made with fresh ingredients. The cafe’s friendly service and reasonable prices make it a popular choice for families and visitors alike. You can expect to pay between ten and fifteen dollars for a satisfying meal.
Frolic Cafe
For a more contemporary brunch experience, head to *Frolic Cafe*. This chic and stylish cafe is known for its innovative menu and vibrant atmosphere. Their avocado toast, topped with everything bagel seasoning, is a must-try. They also offer a selection of creative sandwiches, salads, and bowls, all made with locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Don’t forget to try one of their signature smoothies or a freshly squeezed juice. Frolic Cafe is a great place to relax and enjoy a delicious brunch with friends or family, especially if you are looking for healthier options. Expect the price point to be slightly higher, ranging from twelve to twenty dollars.
Quick Breakfast on the Go
If you need something quick and easy on the go, *David’s Deli* offers breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and coffee to get your day started.
Lunchtime Adventures: Casual and Satisfying Eats
As the day heats up, New Buffalo offers a plethora of options for a quick and satisfying lunch. From casual sandwich shops to relaxed waterfront eateries, there’s something for everyone.
Redamak’s
For a classic beach-town lunch, visit *Redamak’s*. This iconic burger joint has been serving up delicious burgers and fries for generations. Their signature “Redamak’s Burger,” with its juicy patty, melted cheese, and tangy sauce, is a local legend. Grab a burger and fries to enjoy on the beach, or relax on their outdoor patio. Redamak’s is a must-visit for anyone craving a classic American burger experience. Prices are extremely reasonable, making it an ideal choice for families. Expect to spend under ten dollars for a burger and fries.
The Stray Dog Bar and Grill
If you’re looking for a more relaxed sit-down lunch with a stunning view, head to *The Stray Dog Bar and Grill*. Located right on the harbor, this popular restaurant offers a lively atmosphere and a menu filled with delicious seafood, burgers, and sandwiches. Their outdoor patio provides breathtaking views of the lake and the passing boats. The “Lake Perch Sandwich,” a local favorite, features lightly breaded and fried perch fillets served on a toasted bun with tartar sauce and coleslaw. Stray Dog is a great place to unwind and enjoy a delicious meal with friends or family. Lunch entrees generally range from fifteen to twenty-five dollars.
Other Lunch Options
Other quick and easy options include *Casey’s New Buffalo Pizza* for delicious, affordable pizza or *El Rancho Grande* for authentic Mexican cuisine.
Dinner Destinations: Ambiance and Culinary Excellence
As the sun begins to set, New Buffalo transforms into a romantic and enchanting dining destination. The atmosphere shifts from casual to sophisticated, with restaurants offering elegant settings and exquisite culinary experiences.
Bentwood Tavern
For an unforgettable dining experience, reserve a table at *Bentwood Tavern*. This upscale restaurant, located inside the Marina Grand Resort, offers a refined atmosphere and a menu showcasing fresh, seasonal ingredients. The ambiance is elegant and modern, with soft lighting and comfortable seating. Their menu features a variety of dishes, including perfectly seared scallops, succulent steaks, and innovative vegetarian options. Their wine list is extensive, featuring selections from around the world. The service is impeccable, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Expect to pay upwards of forty dollars per entree. Reservations are highly recommended.
Nani’s Cafe
If you’re looking for a waterfront dining experience with breathtaking views, look no further than *Nani’s Cafe*. This charming restaurant, perched on the shores of Lake Michigan, offers a stunning setting and a menu filled with fresh seafood and Italian-inspired dishes. The panoramic views of the lake and the vibrant sunset create a truly magical atmosphere. The “Linguine with Clams,” a classic Italian dish, features tender linguine pasta tossed with fresh clams, garlic, white wine, and a touch of red pepper flakes. The restaurant also offers a selection of other seafood dishes, pasta dishes, and pizzas. Nani’s is a perfect place to celebrate a special occasion or simply enjoy a romantic dinner. Entrees are generally between twenty-five and thirty-five dollars. Reservations are essential, especially during peak season.
Brewster’s Italian Cafe
For a more casual, family-friendly dinner option, *Brewster’s Italian Cafe* is a popular choice. They have a comprehensive menu of Italian specialties as well as great pizza.
Drinks and Nightlife: Unwind and Enjoy
After a delicious dinner, unwind and enjoy New Buffalo’s vibrant nightlife scene. From cozy bars to lively breweries, there’s a place to suit every taste.
Journeyman Distillery (Three Oaks)
*Journeyman Distillery’s* Three Oaks location is a short drive from New Buffalo, but it’s an experience worth the drive. You can tour the distillery, sample their spirits, and enjoy a craft cocktail in their historic building. They also offer a food menu. The ambience is rustic and charming, making it a great place to relax and enjoy the evening.
Sweet Treats and Desserts: Indulge Your Sweet Tooth
No culinary adventure is complete without indulging in a sweet treat. New Buffalo offers a variety of options to satisfy your sweet tooth, from classic ice cream parlors to charming bakeries.
Oink’s Dutch Treat
*Oink’s Dutch Treat* is a local institution, serving up delicious ice cream for generations. Their menu features a wide variety of flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous options like salted caramel and peanut butter cup. They also offer sundaes, milkshakes, and other frozen treats. Oink’s is the perfect place to cool off on a hot summer day and enjoy a delicious ice cream cone.
The Granary
*The Granary* offers a range of pastries and coffees to get your day or sweeten it with cakes and other items.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
Venture beyond the main streets and discover New Buffalo’s hidden culinary gems. These local favorites offer unique experiences and exceptional value.
The Terrace Room
*The Terrace Room*, located at the Harbor Grand, while a bit quieter than other options, gives a perfect view of the harbor. It provides a comfortable and intimate atmosphere with a selection of seafood and regional offerings.
Tips for Dining in New Buffalo
Planning your culinary adventure in New Buffalo? Keep these tips in mind:
Seasonality
Many restaurants in New Buffalo are seasonal, with limited hours or closures during the off-season (typically from late fall to early spring). Be sure to check their hours of operation before you go. The prime dining season is during the summer months.
Reservations
During peak season (summer weekends and holidays), restaurants can get very busy. It’s highly recommended to make reservations, especially for dinner.
Dietary Needs
Most restaurants in New Buffalo are accommodating to dietary restrictions, such as vegetarian, gluten-free, and vegan options. However, it’s always a good idea to call ahead and inquire about specific dietary needs.
Parking
Parking can be limited in New Buffalo, especially during the summer months. Be prepared to walk a few blocks to your destination. There are public parking lots available, but they can fill up quickly.
Conclusion: A Culinary Getaway Awaits
New Buffalo, Michigan, is more than just a picturesque beach town. It’s a culinary destination that offers a diverse and satisfying range of dining experiences. From casual breakfast spots to elegant waterfront restaurants, there’s something to please every palate and budget. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, classic American burgers, or innovative cuisine, you’ll find it in New Buffalo. So, plan your culinary adventure today and discover the delicious side of this Michigan gem. Support local businesses, try something new, and create lasting memories with every bite. The taste of fresh lake perch, the sound of the waves, and the warm hospitality of New Buffalo await.
